In light of the Trump Administration's directive in January 2025 to start imprisoning thousands of migrants at Guantanamo Bay, we are publishing an excerpt from the 2020 book Guantanamo Voices: True Accounts from the World's Most Infamous Prison, which illustrates interviews with 10 people who have experience at the prison.
This chapter from the 2020 book is an interview with Katie Taylor, who at the time worked for human rights group Reprieve providing support for former Guantanamo prisoners. Since 2002, roughly 780 men have been imprisoned in Guantanamo Bay and the vast majority were never charged with a crime. As of February 2025, 15 people remain incarcerated at the prison and President Trump's directive calls for imprisoning up to 30,000 migrants at the facility. Even after people are released from Guantanamo, the painful impacts of their incarceration endure.
![Guantanamo Voices cover](https://www.crucialcomix.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/guantanamo-voices-cover-brown.webp)
![](https://www.crucialcomix.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/Screen-Shot-2025-02-10-at-11.30.16-AM-png.webp)
![Panel one Lines of Arabic on a page. The word spells out “salam” (peace). سلام Panel two Katie’s finger traces the word. Panel three Katie as an 18-year-old college student wearing a Brown University sweatshirt. She is a white woman with sandy-blonde hair. She’s reading an Arabic language textbook on her dorm room bed. She says the word out loud. Katie [narration]: “Arabic just always appealed to me. The script is really pretty.” Katie: Salam. Panel four Katie walking around the leafy New England Brown campus, thinking the Arabic word, looking happy and excited. Panel five In contrast to that green and leafy scene, Katie walking down a hot street in Haifa, outside the Adalah office. It’s clearly a different climate: there’s a palm tree and road signs in Hebrew. Katie: [narration] “After graduation, I got an internship at the Legal Center for Arab Minority Rights in Israel.”](https://www.crucialcomix.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/guantanamo_p1-2.webp)
![Panel one Katie walking through a busy market, full of vegetables and spices. Her eyes are wide, taking it all in. Katie: “I was like a sponge. I was ready to learn.” Panel two A riot in the streets: Palestinians waving flags in front of tires set on fire. Katie: “About six months into my internship, the second intifada broke out.” Panel three Katie watching the scene below from her apartment window. Panel four Crying Palestinians carry the body of a baby who has died. Katie: “I wound up working in Palestine for eight years. Spending most of my twenties there deeply impacted who I am today.”](https://www.crucialcomix.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/guantanamo_p3.webp)
![Panel one Katie in her Reprieve office, talking, modern day. Narration: In 2009, when President Obama announced he would close Guantanamo, human rights organization Reprieve got UN funding to start the Life After Guantanamo program. Katie was hired in 2010. Katie: “If you’re released, it’s not like you step out of Guantanamo and suddenly all of that is behind you and you’ve forgotten it.” Panel two Katie talking on the phone with a client. Katie [narration]: “I think I expected the men to be angrier.” Katie: Okay, tell me what’s going on. Panel three Katie thinking as she listens on the phone. Over the rest of this page, the phone cord from Katie’s phone twists around the page, becoming a complicated, knotted path that travels around a globe with flags marking host countries. Katie [narration]: “A lot of what we do in Life After Guantanamo is shockingly mundane.” Katie: Alright, let me see if I can get someone to your house to install WiFi. Panel four Katie [narration]: “The US government resettled many [detainees] in third-party “host” countries, so many of them are having to rebuild their lives in countries they’d never even set foot in before.” Panel five Katie: “They didn’t speak the language, they didn’t know how to navigate the basic institutions that we use-day to-day. They were just left and expected to get on with their lives.”](https://www.crucialcomix.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/guantanamo_p4.webp)
![Katie sitting in her kitchen at home, eating dinner. Katie: “If you’ve only been dealing within the confines of an arbitrary prison system, it orders the way that you think about the world.” Panel 2 The lights flip off, leaving her in the dark. Katie: “Yesterday, my electricity went out. You don’t really think about it, you just deal with it.” Katie: Oh dang, must be the fuse. Panel 3 A detainee holding a candle in a dark kitchen, very upset. Katie [narration]: “Whereas a torture victim or someone who has been detained indefinitely might think..” Detainee: “What have I done to make this happen?! Why are they doing this to me?!” Panel 4 That same detainee walking down a street in Europe, looking upset and confused. Narration: A core part of the “regime of control” at Guantanamo was to make it impossible for detainees to trust their sense of reality. Panel 5 Narration: This creates a profound sense of paranoia and uncertainty. The detainee seeing his reflection in a CCTV camera.](https://www.crucialcomix.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/guantanamo_p5.webp)
![Panel one A man in Senegal calling on a cell phone, in the middle of the busy city of Dakar. Katie [narration] “In 2016, I remember the day very well. Suddenly, we were getting calls from former Guantanamo detainees from all over the world.” Man: “Hello? Hello? Reprieve?” Panel two Behind the man, a scene of a car accident in the street. Man: “There has been an accident. Someone said to call you.” Panel three Portraits of Salem Abdul Salem Ghereby and Awad Khalifa, with labels. Narration: That’s how Katie and her colleagues first got in contact with two Libyan former detainees living in Dakar. Panel four Scene of bombed-out Tripoli. Narration: While Ghereby and Khalifa had been in Guantanamo, their home had entirely changed. During the Arab Spring, Libyans staged a revolution against dictatorship. It descended into a bloody civil war, with rival factions fighting brutally on all sides. Panel five Khalifa looking through the small window in the door of his cell. Narration: In 2016, as Obama scrambled to transfer prisoners out of Guantanamo, the U.S. government gave the two men a choice: stay in the prison indefinitely or be sent to Senegal.](https://www.crucialcomix.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/guantanamo_p6.webp)
![The two men walking handcuffed, blindfolded, and with earmuffs on down the airstrip at Guantanamo, between guards. Katie: “Agreements between the US governments and host governments are confidential. We never know what the trade-off is, if there is one. There have been rumors over the years that there have been trade deals, money involved. But we can only guess.” Panel two A file stamped “classified” behind handed from a US official to a Senegalese official. Katie: “Each country does it differently, there’s no unity in what the host countries offer or promise. In some countries, they created a whole new legal status just for men from Guantanamo.” Panel three A piece of paper with several citizenship options on it: Citizen, Refugee, Work Permit, and “Other?” The other is checked. Katie: “That was very unhelpful. It was really unclear what rights they had or didn’t have. Can they open a bank account? Can they get a driver’s license? Can they get married? Panel four The two men arriving in Senegal, walking down the street in Dakar, looking uncertain. There is a soldier walking behind them, to keep an eye on them. Katie: “If you put them in an uncertain circumstance where they don’t have legal residence, they don’t know if they’re going to be able to stay there. It adds to their fear of the future. Panel five One of the men looks warily over his shoulder. Katie: “Because they could be tossed out in any moment.”](https://www.crucialcomix.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/guantanamo_p7.webp)
![Panel one An old prosthetic leg sitting in the corner of an apartment. Narration: Life in Senegal had other problems. Khalifa was an amputee and both had vision problems—requests for glasses and a better-fitting prosthetic leg took months. Panel two Ghereby video chatting with his family. Narration: Ghereby’s wife and children were still from Libya. The Senegalese government had not been permitted them to stay with him in Senegal. Panel three As the video chat ends, Ghereby’s apartment feels large and dark. Narration: They were both isolated, away from family and community. Panel four A knock on a door. Panel five A hand sticks a hand-written note to the door, it’s written in Arabic.](https://www.crucialcomix.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/guantanamo_p8.webp)
![Panel one A plane flying overhead. Narration: The New York Times reported that Senegal deported the two men to Libya. Panel two The two men, hooded, being pulled into blackness. Narration: Then, just like they had feared, the men vanished. Panel three The mere outline of the men can be seen. Narration: Are they dead? In prison? Held by a warlord? Panel four Katie: “I know the US could have stopped this. It was horrible, it continues to be horrible.” Panel four Panel five A Close GITMO protest outside the Capitol Building. Narration: The response from the U.S. government was silence. After taking office in 2017, President Trump had abolished the office of an ambassador assigned to help close the Guantánamo Bay prison. Panel six Another scene of the Close GITMO protest. Katie: “I’m very worried about the message that this sends to host countries: nobody’s watching, nobody cares. So for us it’s very important to show that people are watching.”](https://www.crucialcomix.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/guantanamo_p10.webp)
![The image of a shadow-puppet monster stretches across the top of the page. The monster shadow turns out to be cast by a regular man, sitting in a corner with a candle for lighting. Katie: ”I think that here we are, 17 years later, and we’re still saying so many of the things we were saying at the very beginning: this prison is premised on false information.” Katie: “The U.S. government did an extremely good job of fear-mongering since the very beginning. These were monsters, these were people who had perpetrated the worst crime on Americans ever. That was the false messaging and it was quite successful.” Panel two Katie: “I think when you tap into fear, it’s incredibly strong and it’s incredibly moving.”](https://www.crucialcomix.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/guantanamo_p11-scaled.webp)
![Panel one A white supremacist rally in the United States. A man holds a sign saying, “All I need to know about Islam, I learned on 9/11.” “You create this feedback loop when you allow something like this to exist.” Panel two White supremacists holding tiki torches and shouting at the rally in Charlottesville. “The excesses of Guantanamo leak into so many things, both domestically and in terms of our foreign policy.” Panel three A small child crying as her mother is arrested by ICE agents. “There’s been no accountability. Panel four The mother is led away as ICE agents take the child. “And the lack of accountability has meant that the situation replicates itself… Panel five A group of men in Guantanamo pray in the communal room of the prison block. “...and moves on.”](https://www.crucialcomix.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/guantanamo_p12.webp)